AI analysisUses public information; see the source list at the end
Dubai Marina, JVC (Jumeirah Village Circle) and Business Bay are three apartment areas in Dubai that are often compared. This article first sets out what public data can and cannot tell you, then runs three demo units on the same budget through the same method. All three units are demo data, do not correspond to real buildings, and do not represent the future performance of any area.
1. What each area is like
- Dubai Marina: a waterfront high-rise apartment area, and one of the areas open to foreign buyers listed in the annex to the 2006 regulation. Public reports cite an average service charge of about AED 16.1 per sqft per year.
- JVC: a dense mid-market apartment area with plenty of supply. Public reports put its service charge slightly under AED 10 per sqft per year.
- Business Bay: a mixed business and residential area next to the city centre; public reports cite a service charge of about AED 15 per sqft per year.
The service charges above are area-level ranges relayed by agents and have not been rechecked building by building; different buildings in the same area can differ widely, and the DLD Service Charge Index lookup is what counts.
2. How to read public data
Area reports from property portals are mostly based on asking prices and asking rents - the prices agents post online on behalf of owners - not transaction prices registered with DLD. The projected ROI in these reports has no published formula and is measured differently from the yields on this site, which are calculated from annual rent, service charges and one-off costs, so the two cannot be compared directly.
- Listing data is useful for orders of magnitude and ranges, not as transaction prices or future returns.
- Differences between buildings, floors, views and building age within one area are often larger than the average differences between areas.
- Dubai listings use AED and sqft: 1 sqft is about 0.0929 square metres; the AED is pegged to the US dollar at USD 1 = AED 3.6725.
3. Same budget, one unit in each area
The budget is a cash purchase at a price of no more than AED 1,700,000. One ready unit per area is taken from the demo data, and all are calculated on the same basis of 5% vacancy, default rates and pre-tax figures:
| Item | Dubai Marina | JVC | Business Bay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demo unit | Wexbourne Wharf Residences 1-bedroom | Larkmoor Gardens Residences 2-bedroom | Feldbury Quarter Residences 1-bedroom |
| Size (sqft) | 780 | 1,150 | 740 |
| Price (AED) | 1,680,000 | 1,640,000 | 1,612,000 |
| Annual rent (AED) | 103,000 | 117,000 | 108,000 |
| Service charge rate (AED/sqft) | 20 | 14 | 14.5 |
| Annual NOI (AED) | 70,899 | 82,645 | 80,395 |
| Total all-cash investment (AED) | 1,788,260 | 1,745,820 | 1,716,112 |
| Gross rental yield | 6.1% | 7.1% | 6.7% |
| All-cash operating yield | 4.0% | 4.7% | 4.7% |
4. What this table shows and what it does not
- On the same budget, the JVC unit gives the most floor area; the Dubai Marina unit has the highest service charge rate and also the lowest all-cash operating yield.
- The JVC unit is currently vacant, so its annual rent is a demo figure set from an area reference, not a tenancy contract. For vacant units, this site's calculator pre-fills 10% vacancy by default; at 10%, its NOI is AED 76,795 and its all-cash operating yield is 4.4%.
- The Dubai Marina and Business Bay units are tenanted, with rents taken from demo tenancy contracts; whether the rent can be adjusted at expiry is subject to the statutory cap.
- The three figures are just the results for three demo units under the same assumptions. They do not show that any area is better overall, and they do not represent future rents or prices.
5. When you compare for yourself
- Align the basis first - all ready properties, the same vacancy and cost assumptions, all pre-tax - then compare the all-cash operating yield.
- Look up the service charge by building, check whether the rent comes from a tenancy contract or an estimate, and set vacancy according to the unit's status.
- You can put the three units into the calculator's comparison mode, change the assumptions one by one, and see how the results change.
